Disclaimer: Eveswatch.com is reader-supported, meaning that I may include affiliate links in my articles for which I may receive compensation without any additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Tudor watches and Rolex watches are two brands that are known for their beautiful and excellent timepieces in the watch world. Yet while they share the same history and heritage, this sister company targets different audiences as seen in their huge price difference.
Two of their flagship dive watches that are worthy of comparison are the Rolex Submariner and Tudor Black Bay 58. While it’s difficult not to appreciate the luxurious Rolex Submariner which has an all-around exquisite look, excellent manufacturing quality, highly durable material, and has been recognized as the benchmark of diving watches, its price may not be for everyone.
So to capture this niche, Tudor came up with the Black Bay 58, a Rolex-inspired watch with a more accessible price and more common availability.
But is the Tudor Black Bay 58 a viable substitute to the Rolex Submariner or a totally new king in its own market niche? We’ll dismantle both of these questions in this article to help you decide on your own.
If you’re a watch enthusiast or watch nerds who are interested to know more about the Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Rolex Submariner comparison, then keep reading.
Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Rolex Submariner
Rolex and Tudor’s main timepieces are the Submariner and the Black Bay 58. Both watches are meticulously engineered but are unique in their own way. When you look at the nitty-gritty of the Rolex Submariner and the Tudor Black Bay 58, you’ll find that they’re really distinct and appeal to different types of people.
The Rolex Submariner has evolved into a luxury timepiece rather than a practical tool watch throughout time. Many people refer to Rolex’s ceramic bezel (Cerachrom bezel) as well as its oyster steel case as proof. In comparison, most customers of the Tudor Black Bay 58 think of it in the same way they think of aluminum bezels, which are also tried and true timepieces designed to withstand the elements.
Given that, back in the day, selecting between Rolex and Tudor brand was almost unfathomable as they were aiming for distinct demographics. However, the fact that buyers now buy both Rolex and Tudor watches and sometimes compare the two demonstrates the brand’s success.
[You might also want to check out: Tudor Black Bay Chrono Vs Rolex Daytona]
Tudor Black Bay 58 Overview
Rolex’s advancements inspire the Tudor Black Bay. It does, however, have its own style and grace. In 2012, the Black Bay 58 diving watch was introduced to the market. Despite being a more recent model, it bears homage and resemblance to the brand’s earlier vintage dive watches.
The Black Bay 58 has a stainless steel case that is 39mm in diameter and 11.9 mm in thickness. It has a polished and satin finish that gives its clean vibe. It also features the traditional Tudor rose on its prominent winding crown that is very striking.
As a dive watch, the Tudor Black bay 58 has a unidirectional rotating bezel in steel with 60-minute graduation which is an important aspect as this allows divers to monitor their oxygen level. Plus, a water-resistant level of up to 200 meters.
Lastly, The feature and its general appearance are inspired by their model from 1958, hence, Tudor Black Bay 58. So if you love vintage watches, this one’s for you.
- Very versatile timepiece, will look good on all occasions
- Classic aesthetics that will match any style
- Precise movement with its MT5402
- Comfortable and luxurious feel overall
- Reputable brand, trusted quality
- With applied Swiss Super-LumiNova® phosphorescent ensures high legibility even in dark environment
- Available in a wide variety of straps to choose from (stainless steel bracelet, leather strap, and fabric strap)
- Maybe a bit pricey for those not too familiar with timepieces
Rolex Submariner Overview
The Rolex Submariner is the culmination of years of meticulous technological development aside from Rolex Daytona and Rolex Explorer. The Rolex Submariner evolved from prior attempts to produce a watch that truly can withstand the depths of the ocean, making it a fascinating watch for all those who get hold of it. Rolex spent years perfecting the watch’s features and capabilities.
The 41mm Rolex Submariner was the first watch ever developed for the depths of the ocean. The Rolex Submariner, which can withstand water pressure up to 980 feet (300m), surpassed preceding waterproof watch models that could only withstand water pressure up to 660 feet (200m). Deep-sea divers could wear the Rolex Submariner on all deepest dives thanks to its amazing resistance to water pressure.
Another feature to love about this watch is its case and bracelet that is made up of Oyster steel. It is highly resistant to corrosion and provides an exceptional quality that will surely withstand even the harshest environment. Aside from its amazing quality, it is also made to be durable yet comfortable on the wrist.
It also features 60-minute graduation that allows a diver to keep track of their diving time made from a luxurious, scratch-resistant, and corrosion-resistant cerachrom bezel.
- Have been set as the Gold standard of dive watches
- Holds its value well, sometimes appreciate in value
- Built to last, true quality of Rolex
- Chromalight display provides visibility even in dark environment
- Provide very precise timekeeping
- Water resistance up to 300 meters
In-Depth Comparison: Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Rolex Submariner
|Specs||Tudor Black Bay 58||Rolex Submariner|
|Dial||Black Dial||Black Dial|
|Movement||Self-winding mechanical movement with bidirectional rotor system||Perpetual, mechanical, self-winding|
|Bezel||Aluminum Bezel||Ceramic Cerachrom Bezel|
|Crystal||Domed Sapphire Crystal||Scratch-resistant sapphire|
|Power reserve||Approximately 70 hours||Approximately 70 hours|
Quality and Durability
There isn’t anything to criticize in terms of build quality for both timepieces. The Submariner has a somewhat finer finish and features white gold indexes, among other things. However, the Submariner is roughly twice as expensive. Considering this, both watches are of exceptional quality. This includes, among other things, no rattling, a strong and robust case and bracelet, and a spinning bezel that doesn’t feel like it’s made of plastic when wound.
The main distinctions between them are the method and the purpose they are manufactured. The Tudor is a historical model, which means it is constructed with more conventional components. In contrast to the ceramic dial of the Submariner, the Tudor has a matte black dial.
It also features an aluminum bezel insert, whereas the Submariner has a ceramic bezel insert, which is tougher and scratch-resistant. The Black Bay’s case is heavily influenced by old diving watches models from Rolex and Tudor, featuring bevels on the side of the lugs, which Rolex discontinued many years ago.
When comparing the Submariner to the Black Bay, price is obviously a major consideration. The Submariner is more than twice as expensive as the Black Bay. When it comes to the preloved market, the Black Bay tends to depreciate in value, whilst the Submariner tends to sell for more than the original price.
Both Tudor and Rolex put each watch through a battery of tests of the following construction to assure its precision and dependability. They can offer a five-year international guarantee on all new timepieces purchased from one of their Official Retailers because they are confident in their stringent quality assurance.
The Verdict: Which Luxury Watch is Better?
The Rolex Submariner has endured the test of time for many decades. This utilitarian timepiece is a great example of how style and substance may be combined. It blends the functionality of a dive watch with a traditional design that’s appropriate for any occasion.
The Tudor Black Bay, on the other hand, is a good option if you’re searching for a similar model at a considerably lesser price. It may not have the same extensive history as the Submariner, but it takes a lot of design cues from tried-and-true classic models.
To put it simply, you just can’t go wrong with either of them. It’s really up to your personal preferences.
If you like this article, make sure to check out our other articles at Eveswatch.com.