Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay

Disclaimer: Eveswatch.com is reader-supported, meaning that I may include affiliate links in my articles for which I may receive compensation without any additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

If you’re searching for new luxury watches, pocket watches, or dive watches to add to your collection, you’ve come to the right place. 

In this article, we decided to compare and contrast two of the best watch brands and most high-quality luxury timepieces you can find in the market – the Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay.

Here at Eveswatch, we believe that it is normal for watch brands to have a friendly competition for you to find out which brand will suit your preference better.

So if you’re interested to know more about its in-depth comparison, keep reading!

TLDR: Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay

Breitling Superocean

Breitling Superocean

In case you haven’t heard of the Breitling Superocean yet, it is a dive watch that shares several similarities with the Tudor Black Bay. However, the two brands also have their differences. One key feature of Breitling is it produces watches of the luxury spectrum.

Breitling watches feature a case with a length measuring 46-millimeters and its bandwidth measures 24-millimeters. On the other hand, its thickness is 15-millimeters, which is an additional 2-millimeters thicker than the Tudor Black Bay. 

Its lug-to-lug width also measures 20-millimeters, making it look and feel heavier like its previous watches. The Breitling watch’s bezel is ratchet and unidirectional. On the other hand, its dial is available in two different color schemes: black on black or blue and white. 

Other features include a screw-locked winding crown with two gaskets, a Breitling 17 self-winding mechanical caliber, and a cambered sapphire crystal, glare-proofed on both sides of the watch. 

In terms of power reserve, the Breitling Superocean offers roughly 40 hours. Meanwhile, its water-resistance can go up to 200 feet deep. 

Lastly, this luxury watch is produced out of a riveted steel bracelet, including a folding clasp for closure and a satin finish.

Pros

  • Include a ratcheted and unidirectional bezel
  • Offers a dial-in two different color schemes
  • Has luminous hands
  • Provides a screw-locked winding crown with two gaskets
  • Operates in Breitling 17 self-winding mechanical caliber
  • Features a cambered sapphire crystal,  glare-proofed
  • Offers a 40-hour power reserve
  • Water resistant up to 500 feet
  • Includes a riveted steel bracelet
  • Provides a folding clasp
  • Satin finished

Cons

  • None

Interested? Click here to buy it!

Tudor Black Bay

Tudor Black Bay

The Tudor Black Bay is a long-standing watch collection launched in July 2020. Unlike the Tudor Pelagos, the Black Bay offers a vintage vibe and includes more classic-looking features. 

The watch features a case thickness of 39 millimeters and a length of 47 millimeters. Overall, its thickness measures 11.9 and 20-millimeter lugs.

Another key feature of this dive watch is its unidirectional rotatable bezel, including a 60-minute graduated disc and set in steel. This feature also comes in a matte blue color, silver gilded markings and numerals, and an anodized aluminum style.

This watch’s dial includes a domed style and Sapphire and is available in blue or black. Meanwhile, the Tudor rose displayed on the watch’s winding crown. The movement is a MT 5402, including a power reserve that lasts up to 70 hours. This timepiece is also water-resistant up to 200 meters.

Other features to admire about this dive watch include a riveted steel bracelet, which is polished with a satin finish. A folding clasp and safety catch is also provided for a tight closure.

Pros

  • Feature a unidirectional rotatable bezel
  • Water resistant up to 200 meters
  • Offers a power reserve of 70 hours
  • Operates in a MT 5402 movement
  • Displays a Tudor rose on the winding crown
  • Features a domed style and Sapphire crystal in blue or black
  • Includes a riveted steel bracelet, finished in satin
  • Provides a folding clasp and safety catch
  • Features a silicon balance spring

Cons

  • May include minor marks

Interested? Click here to buy it!

In-Depth Comparison of Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay

Specifications

SpecificationsBreitling Superocean IITudor Black Bay
Dial window material typeScratch-resistant Sapphire Domed Sapphire 
ClaspFold Over with Push Button ReleaseDeployment clasp
Case materialStainless steelStainless steel
Case diameter46 mm41 mm
Case thickness15 mm15 mm
Band materialStainless steelStainless steel
Bandwidth 24 mm18 mm
Band colorSilver-toneBlack
Dial colorBlackBlack
MovementUnidirectional rotatingSwiss automatic
Water resistance200 meters200 m
Power reserve40 hours70 hours

Quality and Durability

One interesting fact you should know about the Breitling Superocean and Tudor Black Bay is the surprising partnership of their movements. In 2017, Tudor launched Heritage Black Bay Chrono. Their Tudor caliber MT5813 was dubbed an “in-house” and a mistake by the brand. 

However, the movement turned out to be sourced from Breitling for its manufactured and developed chronograph Caliber B01. Basically, Breitling supplied Tudor with its Caliber B01, while Tudor supplied Breitling with its Caliber MT5612.

Eventually, the Tudor’s Caliber MT5612 was also utilized in the Breitling SuperOcean Heritage II. However, some sources have also said that Tudor cannot develop its Caliber enough to meet SuperOcean II’s expectations.

Warranty

Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay

Yes. The Breitling Superocean and Tudor Black Bay both offer a warranty for all their watches. Breitling offers an international warranty where your watch is guaranteed against any manufacturing defect, as set out under its terms and conditions. This warranty takes effect as of the watch’s date of purchase.

Breitling also offers other warranties, such as Breitling Movements, where they offer two years. They also have Mechanical Manufacture Breitling Movements, where they offer an extended warranty period of five (5) years.

On the other hand, all Tudor watches offer a five-year warranty. A five-year international warranty is guaranteed for watches purchased on or after January 1, 2020. Meanwhile, watches bought from July 1, 2018, to December 31, 2019, will receive an 18-month guarantee extension of three and a half years. 

What Do People Say About It?

Amazon

One satisfied customer was very happy with their purchase of the Breitling Superocean II, so he rated it a good star rating on Amazon. “I received it quickly on time in excellent condition,” he commented.

While a happy customer also gave a positive review of the Tudor Heritage Black Bay Men’s Watch and rated it a good star rating. “As an avid collector of dive watches, I can say that the entire Tudor line is super. Especially with their new in-house movement that can maintain a crazy 70-hour power reserve,” he wrote.

“This luxury watch is a perfect size, its relation to Rolex is obvious. I am not a gold fan of wristwatches, but the very subtle outlines of the dots and hands add some great sizzle to this piece. I own three black bays – one with the older ETA movement and two with the new movement. 

If there is one thing I am not crazy about, it’s the riveted bracelet. But I am in the minority on this. The older versions have the bracelet with no rivets, which I think is cleaner. However, of the three, I think this one gets the most wear.”

YouTube

Marshall Time filmed a video reviewing the Tudor Black Bay 58 and the Breitling Superocean 42. In the video, he compared the two brands in build quality over their design. He described the Breitling watch as a vintage-style looking watch. It is also larger and more contemporary with the 20/20. On the other hand, the Tudor Black Bay watch fits like an old Submariner. 

He also praised Breitling’s polishing, but not so much on the brushing compared to the Breitling Chronomat and other SuperOcean watches. After describing all its excellent features, he preferred the Breitling watch over the Tudor Black Bay for its lume, battery life, water-resistance, and overall quality.

The Verdict: Which Is Best For You?

Breitling Superocean vs Tudor Black Bay

We created an in-depth comparison of the Superocean vs Black Bay watches to help our fellow watch enthusiasts find out which of these two dive watches is better. These watches both share a few similarities and differences, so we created a review to be able to take a closer look.

We highly recommend you to buy the Tudor Black Bay as the better dive watch. This good watch includes excellent features such as 200-meter water resistance, a 70-hour battery life, a domed Sapphire, and an in-house MT 5402 movement. 

If you liked this article, you might want to read our other reviews at EvesWatch.com

Other articles: